Best Dog Bones Review: A Look at Natural and Synthetic Options

This post may contain affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

All dogs should be offered a chew regularly to support the health of their gums and teeth, and both natural and synthetic bone chew options are very popular with dog owners.

Not only are they great for oral health, they can also be fantastic training tools, and help stop any unwanted chewing in and around your home.

In this article, we give some buying advice on what to look for and what to avoid, as well as take a look at some of the best dog bones available on the market, to ensure you get the best bang for your buck, and the best bone chew toy for your pooch.

At a Glance: Our Choice of 6 Best Dog Bones – Natural and Synthetic

• Fido Texas T-Bone Dental Dog Bone
• Petstages Toy Beyond Bone
• Nylabone Dura Chew Combo Packs
• Pet ‘n Shape All Natural Dog Chewz
• Pet ‘n Shape All Natural Knuckle Bone
• Buck Bone Organics Elk Antler

Note: Some of the links above take you to more information, current prices and customer reviews on Amazon.

Which is Best for My Dog – Natural or Synthetic Bone Chews?

When searching for the best dog bones, it can be hard to decide between the range of natural and synthetic choices on offer. Both sets of products have their own benefits and flaws, so it’s down to personal preference when you make your decision about which way to go.

Most dog owners will have heard horror stories about dogs falling ill after being left alone with a bone, but the thing to remember here, is that for the large par, the dog was left alone. Whether the bone is synthetic or natural, the risk to dogs is very tiny, and can often be combated by monitoring the condition of the chews and bones you give them very carefully.

With the biggest part of this decision being down to your preference, to help you decide which would be the best fit for you and your dog, we have rounded up a few of the key similarities and differences for you to consider.

Synthetic Bone Chews:

• Are designed specifically for supporting healthy teeth and gums, with no risk of natural bacteria
• Come in a wide range of sizes and flavors
• Will not stain your carpets or furniture
• Don’t have the calories of treats, so you don’t need to worry about excess weight gain
• Without proper supervision, have been known to break off and cause issues for dogs if ingested

Natural Bone Chews:

• Are naturally attractive to dogs, especially if cartilage etc. is left attached
• Natural bone marrow is full of nutrients that your dog may be missing from their basic diet
• Good quality products will have no added preservatives, meaning all the ingredients are entirely natural to your dog’s digestive system
• Can sometimes cause vomiting and diarrhea, or other issues for dogs who chew them

Once you have decided whether natural or synthetic bones will be best suited to your dog, take a look at our reviews to help you get hold of some of the best options on the market.

A Selection of Some Best Synthetic Bone Chews

Fido Texas T-Bone Dental Dog Bone

This beef flavored chew is really well designed to allow dogs to hold the bone while they chew. Designed to help dogs of all ages, this is a great option for teething puppies, all the way up to older dogs…and everything in between!

What we love:

• Coming in a range of sizes, this large option is a great option for adult Labradors
• The beef flavor is attractive to dogs, and this product uses a slow release flavor system to help keep your dog interested
• The texture is soft and flexible, meaning you can still let your dog enjoy this treat if they’re in their golden years

Points to consider:

• This is a softer product than some others available, so if you have a very keen chewer, this may not last as long as you might have hoped

For most dogs, bones will be one of their favorite toys; they can hide them, run around with them, and most importantly…they can chew them!

Petstages Toy Beyond Bone

This ‘home grown’ pet treat focuses highly on the safety of your dog and the quality of materials used. Durability is on the side of this product, meaning you should be heading to the checkout less.

What we love:

• Even for keen chewers, this product tends to last longer than some of the other chews available
• Made in the USA, you know you can trust the safe sourcing of all the materials used
• Broken teeth should be less of an issue with this product, as it is softer than some others available

Points to consider:

• As with all chew toys, you should make sure your dog doesn’t swallow the material. With this product in particular, check that your dog isn’t scraping off small pieces of plastic during chewing, and remember to replace it once it starts to show signs of wear and tear.

Nylabone Dura Chew Combo Packs

Specifically designed for powerful chewers, this is a great option if you’re forever having to replace bone chews! The fact this is a combo pack means you’re getting fantastic value for money, and the flavor helps add variety to keep your dog interested.

What we love:

• Interesting flavors to help keep your dog occupied
• Keen chewers will still be able to enjoy this long lasting treat
• The clever design means that bristles help clean your dog’s teeth during chewing

Points to consider:

• During chewing, bristles will raise up to help clean your dog’s teeth – do remember though without proper supervision, chews like this can cause issues if your dog rubs it on their tongue etc. and will certainly cause pain for any unsuspecting owners who manage to tread on them!

Selection of Some Best Natural Bone Chews

Pet ‘n Shape All Natural Dog Chewz

Created with larger dogs in mind, this healthy treat is fully digestible. There are no added preservatives in this product, and it is wheat, corn and soy free! Sourced entirely from the USA, you can be confident you’re getting a good quality bone product.

What we love:

• Reliable and responsible USA sourcing, from grass fed, free range cows
• 2 bones are included in the pack, so this offers good value for money
• A great option for larger dogs and keen chewers
• This product is roasted to make sure your dog gets long lasting, high quality flavor

Points to consider:

• As much as the manufacturer wants to achieve a long lasting taste, there’s only so much they can do with a natural bone. Obviously the majority of the flavor will sit on the outside, so once chewed for a while, it may seem less appealing to your dog.

Pet n Shape All Natural Knuckle Bone

If you’re fed up with your dog quickly chewing the standard shaped bones, then this is an option worth trying! The knuckle bone shape means dogs can be amused by this for hours, and this particular product still has the cartilage and soft tissue, meaning your dog gets a good teeth cleaning session while they chew.

What we love:

• There are no artificial additives, and it’s sourced from grass fed cattle
• Where many bones will splinter once chewed, this bone tends to crumble, meaning there’s less of a health risk for your dog
• The shape of this bone makes it great for large dogs and keen chewers – it will take even the most aggressive chewer a while to start to break down this bone

Points to consider:

• As with many natural bone products, be careful on carpets and furniture as staining is a fairly common problem

Buck Bone Organics Elk Antler

While this product might seem more expensive than an average bone, it’s important to notice you get 3 or 4 antlers in each pack, meaning the higher cost is less of an issue than it first appears. Responsible sourcing means only naturally shed antler is used, and every product is from the USA.

What we love:

• Each antler chew is sanitized immediately before being packed, meaning there’s no risk of contamination
• They tend to last fairly well with keen chewers
• Unlike some other natural bone products, they’re unlikely to cause digestive upset because of how they’re sanitized

Points to consider:

• Because they’re sanitized antlers rather than bones attached to cartilage etc. there is less of a smell from the bone, meaning some dogs may be less likely to go for this product.

Conclusion

The main point to remember here is there is no ‘better’ option for every dog – you simply need to choose the product you think best suits you and your dog’s personality.

The great thing about bone chews is they’re fairly affordable. So if you’re unsure about what type your dog will prefer, why not give a few different brands a try?

You may end up with a couple of un-chewed bones, but if you can find a product your dog loves, you can say goodbye to chewed furniture and shoes, and hello to great oral hygiene.

Product image credits: © Chewy.com

Please be aware this page contains affiliate links and LabradorTrainingHQ receives a small commission if you make any purchases through any such links. This has absolutely no effect on the eventual price that you pay and we are very grateful for your support.

Save this to Pinterest:

Top Picks For Our Dogs

1. BEST PUPPY TOY
   We Like: Calmeroos Puppy Toy w/ Heartbeat and Heat Packs - Perfect for new puppies. Helps ease anxiety in their new home.
2. BEST DOG CHEW
   We Like: Bones & Chews Bully Sticks - All of our puppies love to bite, nip, and chew. We love using Bully Sticks to help divert these unwanted behaviors.
3. BEST DOG TREATS
   We Like: Crazy Dog Train Me Treats - One of our favorite treats for training our service dog puppies.
4. BEST FRESH DOG FOOD
   We Like: The Farmer's Dog - A couple months ago we started feeding Raven fresh dog food and she loves it! Get 50% off your first order of The Farmer's Dog.

For a list of all the supplies we get for our new service dog puppies check out our New Puppy Checklist on the PuppyInTraining.com blog.